10

• The problem definition and the research questions are excellently motivated, with underlined urgency and scientific, technological and societal relevance for the present and the future;
• The choice of an approach to solve the problem is visionary, original and argued to be future-proof and possibly applicable to other fields;
• The relevance of the problem must be supported by examples and evidences (e.g. literature);
• The paper decomposes the main problem, in a motivated way, into manageable and clear sub-problems;
• The discussion of the paper maintains full control over all assumptions;
• There are relevant illustrative qualitative and quantitative examples;
• The hypothetical solutions of the problem are argued to be far reaching;
• The paper manages complexity and presents difficult concept in an pleasantly comprehensive way;
• The problem definition, the research questions and project objectives are connected in visionary ways which go beyond the narrow field of the project (e.g. various applications, enabling technologies).

9

• Motivated problem definition and research questions with underlined scientific and technological relevance;
• The paper analyses and scrutinizes the problem definition, e.g. why the problem is relevant and not solved yet by others, what makes it possible to solve the problem now;
• The addressed problems are quantified;
• Relevant qualitative examples which illustrate the problem are given;
• The main problem is exposed as topical and urgent;
• The choice of an approach to solve the problem is clearly motivated and compared to alternatives;
• Clear links to applications and utilization are given;
• Alternative hypothetical solutions with respect to the SOTA and trends in the field are discussed;
• The problem definition, the research questions and the project objectives are connected in deep and original ways.

8

• The addressed problem(s) and research question(s) become quickly and easily clear (efficient exposition);
• The main problem is profoundly motivated via different angles, e.g. both own analysis and literature sources;
• The choice of an approach to solve the problem is clearly motivated;
• Relevant examples are given;
• Specific examples are given on how a bigger problem can be decomposed into manageable smaller challenges;
• The set goals of the work are clear and realistic;
• The problem definition, the research questions and project objectives are logically connected.

7

• There are explicit problem definitions, research questions and goals of the project;
• The addressed problem is clear and made explicit;
• Examples are given;
• The approach to solve the problem in the paper is clear and made explicit;
• The report is focused;
• The problem definition and project objectives are connected.

6

• The goals of the paper and the addressed problem can be inferred from the text;
• The target application is mentioned;

When giving feedback for a specific grade, please select its corresponding channel in the chat-box below ↧. Thanks!

Go to the Report category →